3 Best Peanut Butters For Dogs (Science Based)

It goes without saying that dogs will eat anything but dogs actually really love peanut butter as it seems you've noticed, it’s like a dog’s own kryptonite.

It can work as a healthy treat to give your dog for being a good boy as it's packed with protein, good fats, and nutrients.

Or if you're being devious;  for hiding their medication when you have tried slipping it into their kibble with no avail. 

One favorite way of using peanut butter for our dogs is to stick some on the bathroom tiles to keep them occupied whilst bathing them. It may be messy, but hey, it works! 

So what's the best peanut butter for dogs?

Before I share my recommendations here's why you can trust them...

I spent 20+ hours understanding the health benefits of Peanut butter for dogs including what ingredients they can't eat by consulting the website of top Veterinary Experts and dog bloggers.

My research shows me these are the best peanut butter brands for dogs... 

DISCLOSURE: TridentK9.org is reader supported so if you buy any products featured on this site I may earn an affiliate commission (at no extra cost to yourself). As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. 
You can read my full disclosure here for more information.


Dog’s Best Friend

When you care so much about your furry friend, you will only want to give them the best of the best.

We have searched through the best peanut butter for dogs and found the top option for your best friend. 

Our top pick is the Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder.

This peanut butter is specifically formulated with your dog in mind, for a healthy, reliable and safe snack.

Never again will you have to worry about what is in your dog’s favorite treat as this peanut butter is 100% natural and organic. 

The Bark Bistro Company cares about your dog with their Buddy Budder.

This formula includes no syrups, stabilizers, xylitol, or artificial sugars or salt in their blend. For a healthy, natural and tasty snack, the Bark Bistro delivers. 

Even better, this peanut butter for dogs comes in a wide variety of different flavors, including pumpkin, banana, and berry whilst still remaining completely natural and safe for dogs!

With a thick, creamy and chunky consistency, you can use this dog peanut butter to feed your dogs with a spoon, from a lickmat, or even to disguise their pills and medication.

You can even put this peanut butter in the refrigerator for a thicker texture, or use it to make delicious baked goods for your best bud’s birthday!

For a peanut butter that will make you and your dog very happy, go for the Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder.

OUR TOP PICK

Bark Bistro Company, Ruff R uff Raw Buddy Budder, 100% Natural Dog Peanut Butter, Healthy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, Stuff in Toy, Dog Pill Pocket, - Made in USA, (17 oz Jars)

If you are looking for only the best peanut butter for your furry friend, then you will want to try the Bark Bistro Company Buddy Budder.

This peanut butter is specifically formulated for dogs, made of raw, natural and organic ingredients such as peanuts and honey. 

For a completely pawsome blend, this formula includes no fructose, corn syrup, stabilizers, xylitol or artificial sweeteners.

With a creamy consistency, you can give this peanut butter to your dog for a healthy snack, to hide pills, or to keep them occupied for hours. 

What is even better is that this peanut butter will not upset your dog’s stomach or digestive system, and is completely safe for them to eat!

This peanut butter for dogs is all natural, made of only the best and finest ingredients, and even comes in a wide variety of flavors for a tasty treat your pet will love. 

Pros

  • Natural and organic ingredients

  • Wide variety of flavors to choose from

  • Does not aggravate stomach.

  • Suitable for all ages

  • No stabilizers or additives

  • Does not include xylitol which can be bad for dogs. 

  • Creamy, thick consistency to hide medication

Cons

  • Comes in small package.

EDITORS CHOICE

Green Coast Pet All Natural Pawnut Butter For Dogs, 16 Ounce Jar

If you want a natural peanut butter with no dangerous ingredients for your dog, try Green Coast Pawnut Butter

With Green Coast Pawnut Butter, you can fill your dogs toys with a tasty and tantalizing treat that they will surely enjoy.

This all natural peanut butter is made from premium ingredients with no added salt, sugar, oils or preservatives for a healthy snack for your pup

This peanut butter is made from just two organic and wholesome ingredients, real whole peanuts and flaxseeds.

With raw, natural ingredients included, this peanut butter is an excellent source of healthy protein and omega 3 for a smooth coat and skin in your dog. 

This peanut butter has a thick and creamy texture, making it a great choice for coating your dogs pills and tricking them into eating them!

Pros

  • Natural peanut butter so your dog only gets nutrients and goodness. 

  • Organic ingredients

  • Made from only 2 ingredients

  • Thick, creamy texture that dogs love.

  • No added salt, sugar or oils so not unhealthy.

  • Promotes healthy coat and skin

Cons

  • Small jar

BEST VALUE

2 Packs All Natural Peanut Butter for Dogs Poochie Butter 12oz

If you are looking for a natural peanut butter with added ingredients for wellness and performance, then the Poochie All Natural Peanut Butter will be just right for you and your dog. 

With this peanut butter, you are assured of no preservatives, harmful chemicals and only the best organic ingredients.

In addition, this formula includes dry roasted peanuts for natural B vitamins and fiber, and cinnamon for regulated blood sugar levels.

It even has parsley for great smelling breath, ginger for natural anti-inflammatory properties and coconut oil for a healthy coat and skin in your dog!

The benefits with this peanut butter for dogs are endless.

For a highly healthy snack for your dog, you will want to invest in the Poochie Peanut Butter. 

Pros

Cons

  • If you're on a budget then this is a higher end product.

RUNNER UP

Hyper Pet IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter (100% Natural-Xylitol Free Peanut Butter for Dogs-Use IQ Treat Mat Lick Mat for Dogs) Dog Treats, Dog Snacks & Pill Pockets for Dogs-Natural

For a completely natural, reliable and xylitol free peanut butter for your dog, you will want to try the Peanut Butter spread from Hyper Pet.

This peanut butter is so good, you will want to eat it yourself, and you probably could. 

It is made from all natural ingredients for a smooth and delicious peanut butter that your dog will love!

Made from freshly roasted peanuts and honey, this butter is an amazing source of protein, healthy fats, vitamins B and E for a well balanced diet and a very happy doggie. 

The Hyper Pet Peanut Butter is made or premium ingredients, with responsibly sourced and US made peanut butter.

It is completely xylitol free, with no fructose, corn syrup, stabilizers or artificial additives. It is only made with organic, wholesome ingredients that still packs a lot of flavor that your dog will thank you for. 

Keep your dog occupied with this tasty, terrific peanut butter for dogs. 

Pros

Cons

  • A premium product with a matching price tag.

RUNNER UP

Big Spoon Roasters Wag Butter - Peanut Butter for Dogs - All Natural & Healthy Dog Peanut Butter - Puppy Treats & Snacks – No Gluten, Soy, or Palm – Made in The USA - 13 Ounce Jar

If you are looking for a premium, all natural peanut butter for your dog, then you are in the right place.

The Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Butter for dogs is the perfect peanut butter for your furry friend.

It is sugar and salt free, with no palm oil, stabilizers or fruit syrup, making it safe for your dog.

This peanut butter is not only safe and healthy, but delicious and flavorsome too. Just ask your dog.

Peanut butter is a canine superfood which is perfectly nutritional and full of healthy proteins and omega 3 and 6 fatty acids for healthy muscles, joints, skin and coats. 

The Big Spoon Roasters Wag Butter is made from freshly roasted peanuts, organic coconut oil and chia seeds for a nutritious treat that is even suitable and safe for humans.

Use this peanut butter to distract your dog or hide their pills for a delicious healthy snack.

Pros

  • Organic
  • No additives
  • No palm oil.
  • Nutritional with omega 3 and 6 
  • Made with freshly roasted peanuts
  • Improves coat and digestion

Cons

  • A higher end product with a price tag to match.

RUNNER UP

Kong Real Peanut Butter Tube 5oz

If you are looking for a peanut butter spread to use on your dogs toys and KONG products, then KONG have created a peanut butter specifically for these uses.

The Kong Real Peanut Butter is made from all natural ingredients, making it perfectly safe for your dog. 

The formula is made from fresh roasted peanuts, and natural ingredients for a tasty and lovable result that your dog will enjoy.

This peanut butter is made for dogs, formulated to simply squirt easily inside slow release toys and products in order to keep your dog occupied for long periods of time, making it perfect for busy dogs! 

Pros

Cons

  • Contains hydrogenated oil
  • Contains some sugars

RUNNER UP

Kong Peanut Butter 8oz Pack of 2

Kong also creates a squirty peanut butter paste for their more tricky dog toys. This paste is irresistible and delicious for dogs, helping them to engage in long lasting playtime and distraction. 

If you just want a squirty peanut butter treat for your dog to play with their toys for longer, then you will just need this easy to use peanut butter paste. 

Pros

  • Made for KONG toys
  • Peanut butter flavor
  • 2 pack
  • Squirty consistency
  • Easy to use
  • Keeps dogs occupied for longer

Cons

  • Peanut butter flavored- may not contain real ingredients
  • Includes preservatives and artificial ingredients

Best Peanut Butter For Dogs Buying Guide

What to look for in peanut butter for dogs

With so many different types of peanut butter for dogs available on the market, it can be hard to find the right one for your pet.

This is why we have created a buyer’s guide of the best things to look out for when purchasing peanut butter for your dog

The most important thing to consider when buying peanut butter for your dog is that it cannot contain xylitol.

This is a harmful additive to many peanut butter products that are not safe for your dog. In addition, many peanut butters will contain trans fats that can cause heart disease and diabetes in dogs.

These trans fats and sugars are usually found in non natural peanut butters, or products that have an extended shelf life, so make sure that you check the label of the peanut butter that you are purchasing.

This is why it is so vital that you purchase peanut butter that is specifically formulated for consumption by dogs.

These peanut butters are more likely to be made of natural ingredients, and will not have toxic additives or unhealthy preservatives included.

With this in mind, you will want to ensure that the peanut butter you purchase for your dog will not have fructose, corn syrup, stabilizers, artificial sweeteners, sugars or salt.

You will need a peanut butter that has all natural, organic and healthy ingredients to ensure that it is safe for your dog to consume. 

Dogs can also have highly sensitive guts and stomachs, and so you will need to ensure that the peanut butter you are purchasing is delicate on the digestive system. With that in mind, some dogs can still be more sensitive to certain ingredients than others.

Try to choose peanut butter formulas with natural ingredients or less ingredients included to ensure that they will not suffer after eating.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can dogs eat peanut butter?

Dogs can really love peanut butter. As long as it does not contain any harmful ingredients or additives, it can also be a great source of protein for them, and a healthy snack.

Dogs can eat most natural peanut butters as long as they do not have xylitol, which is unsafe for dogs. 

The best way to give your dogs peanut butter is through a product entirely intended for consumption by dogs. 

Peanut butter is also a common ingredient in dog treats and snacks, and is a great way to hide medication or give your dog a reward.

Why give dogs peanut butter?

There are many reasons why you might want to give your dog peanut butter. Dogs can really enjoy peanut butter. There are so many interactive toys where you can stick a little spoonful of peanut butter and let your dog spend hours licking and playing.

In addition, you may want to hide medication or pills that you need to give to your dog by placing them in some peanut butter and feeding it to your pet.

The best thing about doggie peanut butter is that it can be baked into homemade treats for your dog. This means that you can finally make them a cake for their birthday that they can enjoy!

Is peanut butter healthy for dogs?

Peanut butter can be a healthy snack for dogs, as long as it is given in moderation, and in forms that are not harmful to canines.

Natural peanut butter is a fantastic source of protein and vitamins, including both B and E vitamins that are healthy for your dog.

Peanut butter can also include healthy monounsaturated fats which will be safe for your dog to consume.

It is important to remember that whilst peanut butter is a healthy snack for your furry friend, all good things have to be taken in moderation, and a little goes a long way. 

Does KP peanut butter contain xylitol?

It's not recommended to feed your dog any Peanut Butter that is not specifically manufactured for dogs as it may contain Xylitol which is not safe for dogs, so always read the label before you feed your dog.

How can I keep my dog occupied with peanut butter?

We all know how bathtime can be a struggle with a dog. They squirm, and sometimes hate the water and try to get out.

The same goes for when you are trying to clip their nails, and they will not stay still. The best way to counteract this is to keep them occupied whilst you wash or trim their claws.

We recommend sticking a little bit of dog peanut butter onto the bathroom tiles, or even onto a sticky mat to keep them focusing on licking it all off whilst you finish the task at hand.

Our favorite is the Zolen Dog Slow Treater Lick Pad.

Last update on 2021-04-11 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API